RESEARCH
Over the last decades, consumers in highly developed markets have experienced two important trends: (1) they have more and more options from which to choose, but they are frequently overwhelmed by the choice prospects; (2) they spend more and more of their disposable income on consumption experiences (e.g., dining out, seeing movies, vacationing). My research focuses on both of these developments.
When, Why, and How Consumers Benefit from a Large Number of Choices
In one stream of research I strive to understand when, why, and how consumers benefit from the ubiquitous array of choices in highly developed markets. In doing so, I examine the role of marketer-provided product organizations in the form of (1) orderings and (2) categories. My research shows that the presence or absence of marketer-provided organizations, either in the form of orderings or in the form of categorization, critically determines (a) how consumers search and (b) whether or not providing more choices benefits consumers. When assessing benefits to consumers and marketers, I examine a range of objective (preference match/decision quality, prices paid) and subjective outcomes (satisfaction with the shopping experience and the chosen option). While both orderings and customizations are powerful tools, my research provides a nuanced understanding of how different types of marketer provided organizations benefit consumers and marketers (e.g. more or less accurate orderings, benefit-based vs. attribute-based or complement-based vs. substitute-based categorizations).
How People Evaluate Experiences That Unfold Over Time
In another stream of research I focus on how people evaluate experiences. Characteristics of experiences are that (a) they unfold over time and (b) consumers’ judgments of them are greatly impacted by what occurs before and after these experiences take place. For example, a vacation provides enjoyment over the days it takes place, but anticipating and planning that vacation may also affect one’s evaluations of the experience, both while it unfolds and retrospectively. Furthermore, memories of the vacation are important to people. What people remember and share with others can also affect their retrospective evaluations of the experience.
My research in this area tries to understand which factors influence peoples’ evaluations of experiences. I consider (1) the nature of the experience itself, (2) the activities and events that take place during the experience, and (3) information and psychological processes that precede or follow the experience. These factors can affect evaluations of an experience not just while it unfolds, but also retrospectively.
Research Papers
Jennifer D'Angelo, Kristin Diehl and Lisa A. Cavanaugh (2019) “Lead by Example? Custom-Made Examples Created by Close Others Lead Consumers to Make Dissimilar Choices,“ Journal of Consumer Research.
Alixandra Barasch, Gal Zauberman and Kristin Diehl (2018) “How the Intention to Share Can Undermine Enjoyment: Photo-Taking Goals and Evaluation of Experiences,“ New York University, Yale and University of Southern California - Marshall School of Business.
Hae Eun Chun, Kristin Diehl, Deborah MacInnis (2017) "Savoring an Upcoming Experience Affects Ongoing and Remembered Consumption Enjoyment ," Journal of Marketing.
Valsesia Francesca, Kristin Diehl, Joseph Nunes (2017) "Based On a True Story: Making People Believe the Unbelievable ," Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 71, 105-110.
Gal Zauberman, Jaqueline Silverman, Kristin Diehl, Alixandra Barasch (2017) "Photographic Memory: The Effects of Photo-Taking on Memory for Auditory and Visual Information ," Psychological Science.
Kristin Diehl, Gal Zauberman, Alixandra Barasch (2016) "How Taking Photos Increases Enjoyment of Experiences ," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
Kristin Diehl, Erica van Herpen, Cait Lamberton (2015) "Organizing Products with Complements versus Substitutes: Effects on Effort, Assortment Perceptions and Store Preference ," Journal of Retailing.
Cait Lamberton, Kristin Diehl (2013) "Retail Choice Architecture: The Effects of Benefit and Attribute-based Assortment Organization on Consumer Perceptions and Choice ," Journal of Consumer Research.
Cait Lamberton, Kristin Diehl (2013) "Retail Choice Architecture: The Effects of Benefit and Attribute-based Assortment Organization on Consumer Perceptions and Choice ," Journal of Consumer Research.
Gal Zauberman, Jonathan Levav, Kristin Diehl, Rajesh Bhargave (2010) "1995 Feels so Close Yet so Far: The Effect of Event Markers on Subjective Feelings of Elapsed Time ," Psychological Science 21, 133-139.
Kristin Diehl, Cait Poynor (2010) "Great Expectations?! Assortment Size, Expectations and Satisfaction ," Journal of Marketing Research 47, 312-322.
Lisa Abendroth, Kristin Diehl (2006) "Now or Never: Effects of Limited Opportunities on Information Processing, Purchase Behavior, and Regret ," Journal of Consumer Research 33, 342-351.
Gal Zauberman, Kristin Diehl, Dan Ariely (2006) "Hedonic versus Informational Evaluations: Task Dependent Preferences for Sequences of Outcomes ," Journal of Behavior Decision Making 19, 191-211.
Kristin Diehl (2005) "When Two Rights Make A Wrong: Searching Too Much in Ordered Environments ," Journal of Marketing Research 42.
Kristin Diehl, Gal Zauberman (2005) "Searching Ordered Sets: Evaluations From Sequences Under Search ," Journal of Consumer Research 31, 824-832.
Christine Moorman, Kristin Diehl, David Brinberg, Blair Kidwell (2004) "Subjective Knowledge, Search Locations, and Consumer Choice ," Journal of Consumer Research 31.
Kristin Diehl, Laura Kornish, John Lynch (2003) "Smart Agents: When Lower Search Costs for Quality Information Increase Price Sensitivity ," Journal of Consumer Research 30, 56-71.